commercial-aq-monitor-thumbnail

Monitoring VOCs Indoors

Some VOCs, such as formaldehyde and benzene, are especially hazardous to health
Download Guide

Back to Industry Guides

The legal limits on emissions of and exposure to VOCs vary from place to place, and are set by authorities including the European Union and the United States Occupational Safety and Health Administration OSHA. In the UK, there are currently no indoor air quality guidelines for individual volatile organic compounds. In their absence, the recently revised Department for Education Guidance BB101: Ventilation, thermal comfort and indoor air quality (DfE, 2018) recommended the use of the WHO (2010) Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) guidelines.

Commercial AQ Monitor Comparison

Some VOCs, such as formaldehyde and benzene, are especially hazardous to health. The importance of measuring and controlling such VOCs is recognised in keener guidelines on air quality, and a more broad concern about air quality from employers and the general public.

The selective measurement of formaldehyde and benzene is not readily achieved without recourse to sample gas pre-conditioning. That usually means pneumatics which enable the target gas to be separated, either chromatographically (‘micro-GC’) or chemically (‘benzene tubes’, ‘chem tubes’). In such devices the sensor is only part of the cost, and supporting pneumatics, and in the case of tubes, manual handling and disposal, raise the cost and limit the deployment of selective devices. There is now a large market for sensors of fairly low power demand (10’s mA), at a price point of ~$100’s or less, which measure many, if not most of the VOCs that impact on air quality to provide a measure of the total VOC concentration (TVOC). This lack of selectivity would at first glance seem to fatally compromise such a sensor. After all, many VOCs such as as ethanol cause little concern at concentrations many thousands of times the concentration at which benzene or formaldehyde, say, are harmful. However, generic VOC measurements are attractive and effective because:

  • unpolluted air contains very low TVOC levels, enabling measurement of any polluting VOC at low concentrations.
  • in polluted air, the source and identity of VOCs can often be anticipated e.g., hydrocarbons in a service station.
  • VOCs often ‘co-present’: a TVOC signal may act as a marker for the presence of a particular hazardous VOC, eg benzene co-presented with other VOCs, or even the detection of a generic condition, eg a kitchen in need of ventilation.
  • the ability to sense many VOCs with one sensor provides a commercial economy of scale

These attributes endorse TVOC detection as a diagnostic for indoor ventilation or other actions which limit human exposure to specific and hazardous compounds in air. They should help us to rate the performance of TVOC sensing technologies. In this document three commercial TVOC sensors, the metal oxide sensor, the electrochemical sensor and the photoionisation detector (PID), are compared in the light of these considerations. Much more comprehensive comparisons of the commercial VOC sensors are available, but they tend not to provide a general overview as is intended here. In this document, no critique of any specific technology or manufacturer is intended. Indeed it attempts only to present the author’s own subjective view of commercial sensors.

L.Spinelle, M.Gerboles, G.Kok, T.Sauerwal, ‘Review of low-cost sensors for the ambient air monitoring of benzene and other volatile organic compounds’; EUR 27713; doi: 10.2788/05768

The Metal Oxide Semiconductor Sensor (MOS)

Some Metal Oxide Sensors (MOS) sensors include humidity measurement to enhance measurement integrity, but the effect of this weakly reducing gas in the presence of a VOC is clearly not additive. The minimum detection limit is also very much a question as to how long one is prepared to wait. It also means that specifications for the sensor need careful interpretation.

The Electrochemical Sensor (ETO)

The distinct advantage of the electrochemical sensor over the metal oxide sensor (MOS) is a sensor response to VOC concentrations extending to 10’s ppm, but most especially, this linearity extends down to near zero VOC concentrations, and the relative response to different VOCs does not change significantly with VOC concentration.

Photoionisation Detection (PID)

In recent years, commercial photoionisation detection (PID) sensors have progressively improved in performance at the lower limit of detection. Background currents of just a few ppb TVOC (isobutylene equivalent) have been measured, with PID delivering a resolution to less than 1 ppb, and linearity within ±10% in the range 0 to 10 ppm.

Download our guide to discover more information regarding each sensor and the benefits of each…

Download our FREE Guide

“Commercial AQ Monitor Comparison”

The commercial AQ monitor comparison guide which can be downloaded below provides the reader with an in-depth balance of knowledge regarding the main advantages and disadvantages of the AQ VOC sensors under review; MOS, ETO & PID. It is probably fair to say that the identified disadvantages of the sensors are all a matter of intense research on the part of sensor manufacturers and their technology partners. AQ sensors are commonly deployed with other sensors, such as for CO2 and particulates, which may influence the cost and performance expected of the VOC sensor.

commercial-aq-monitor-comparison

Download Guide

Related Guides

Benzene Detection – Fixed Instruments

Benzene Detection (Fixed Instruments) - ION Science's Fixed Photoionisation Detectors protect workers and the public from benzene exposure

View Details

Gas Detection Equipment – Choosing The Right Type

Knowing which is the best gas detection equipment when so many are available within the market, yet they all seem to do the same job until close inspection.

View Details

Gas Detection Instrument – Do you Require One In Your Industry?

The Gas detection Instrument guide will help you understand the requirement for each type of instrument and which will be best suited to your industry.

View Details

Indoor Air Volatiles Monitored By PID

In most indoor environments, air contains common indoor air volatiles which are readily detectable by PID at a total VOC concentration of a few 10's ppb.

View Details

Monitoring Indoor Air For VOCs

Given the range of VOC’s in air and their variable harmfulness, it might seem preferable to monitor the more ubiquitous and harmful of them individually.

View Details

Photoionisation Detection Sensors For Monitoring VOCs Indoors

PPM Gas Sensor – MiniPID 2

Range: 0 to 4000 ppm. Minimum detection limit: 100 ppb. 10.6 eV lamp. The PPM gas sensor - MiniPID 2 is designed for detecting VOCs over the widest dynamic range on the market without compromising performance.

Product Details
PPB Gas Sensor – MiniPID 2

Range: 0 to >40 ppm. Minimum detection limit: 1 ppb. 10.6 eV lamp. The PPB gas sensor - MiniPID 2 is optimised to deliver an exceptionally low background which allows for optimum low-end sensitivity.

Product Details
10.0 eV Gas Sensor – MiniPID 2

Range: 0 to >100 ppm. Minimum detection limit: 5 ppb. 10.0 eV lamp. The 10.0 eV gas sensor - MiniPID 2 is used for enhanced selectivity of compounds with lower ionisation energies.

Product Details
11.7 eV Gas Sensor – MiniPID 2

Range: 0 to >100 ppm. Minimum detection limit: 100 ppb. 11.7 eV lamp. The 11.7 eV gas sensor lamp extends the range of detectable compounds, only available from ION Science.

Product Details
High Sensitivity Gas Sensor – MiniPID 2

Range: 0 to 3 ppm. Minimum detection limit: 0.5 ppb. 10.6 eV lamp. The high sensitivity gas sensor, is the highest sensitivity gas sensor for sub PPB level detection.

Product Details
Sensor Development Kit (SDK)

Sensor Development Kit (SDK) for the integration of the MiniPID 2 photoionisation sensor.

Product Details

Download your FREE Guide

Simply complete the form below to obtain your FREE Guide on “Commercial AQ Monitor Comparison”.